This is by no means the first Asimov book I’ve read. I was given his Complete Robot Collection and the Foundation trilogy for my 18th birthday and that was enough for me to absolutely fall in love with his style of writing, not to mention the wide variety of science fiction ideas that still fit into one consistent future narrative (with a few exceptions). Having said that, most of the stories in this particular collection touch the main part of his future narrative only tangentially.
Marooned Off Vesta: His first published story, written when he was 18, deals with three survivors of a spaceship hit by an asteroid and caught in orbit around an inhabited asteroid, Vesta. One thing I love about Asimov’s short stories is the way he allows his characters to come to life through their dialogue, with minimal physical description. Whilst reading, I did guess the resolution – how they reach Vesta – but that didn’t detract from the suspense of the second half of the story in which they execute their plan.
Nightfall: It is perhaps appropriate that my first time reading this one is in the run up to the 21st December 2012. A society living on a planet with six suns, with an absolute fear of darkness, no concept of stars and, hence, no concept of the sheer scale of the universe. It describes the society’s preparation for an approaching apocalypse, weaving together spiritual interpretation and scientific prediction. It is hard not to scoff at their theories, from our perspective. It makes one think about the connection between the environment, the planet, we’re used to and the way that affects how we see the universe.
The C-Chute is more a study of human nature and our motivations, set in a science fiction style hostage situation. It is also a demonstration of Asimov’s “tell a gripping yarn, then sucker punch the reader with the final line” technique, which is awesome.
The Martian Way was written during the McCarthy Era (I had to look it up) and is one of the few stories here where the context does help you to get to the heart of the story. I think this is possibly my favourite story in the collection, taking the mick out of politicians and campaigners who jump on a bandwagon without really thinking about an issue. The main characters are also infused with that pioneering spirit with regards to space exploration that our society has lost in the past 50 years.
The Deep looks at the human race, in particular our social bonds, from the perspective of an alien species. It suffers from a rather unsympathetic main character, I think. It’s not bad; it’s just hard to relate to.
The Fun They Had is a short sketch, written for children, that perfectly encapsulates the sentiment of “the grass is always greener on the other side.”
The Last Question: First, a bit of advice, if you read this story in an anthology, do not read the foreword. I was influenced slightly by Asimov’s description of it – he built it up and so I didn’t enjoy it as much as I thought I would. Having said that, it’s an interesting idea for the future of humans and computing, and one of his more structured stories. Despite myself, I was grinning at the end (getting a few funny looks from the people opposite me on the bus!)
The Dead Past: a story covering the dangers of, not time travel itself, but being able to view the past and why, sometimes, we should trust the authorities when they keep the general public in the dark about something. I particularly liked the view of a future scientific community where everyone has to be extremely specialised to push at the frontiers of knowledge. Well, perhaps “found it interesting” is more accurate than saying “I liked it”, I think there’s a certain creativity in scientific innovation that requires overlap between fields.
The Dying Night: a reunion of university classmates results in a death and the loss of an important scientific breakthrough. The group wish to solve it discreetly and so consult a reclusive private detective who merely needs to hear the story before deducing the culprit. It’s Asimov writing a Sherlock Holmes/Poirot story in a science fiction setting. It’s very enjoyable, although one perhaps needs a little astronomical knowledge to solve the mystery before the reveal. Or I need to pay more attention when reading a murder mystery, that’s possible too…
Anniversary: written in 1959 for the 20th anniversary of Marooned Off Vesta and set on the 20th anniversary of the crash, revisiting the trio from the original story. It feels indulgent at first, but that’s not a bad thing. In fact, indulgence or living off a past triumph becomes the driving force of the story. The story is deeper than it appears at first. One could argue that it predicts the fate of astronauts like Buzz Aldrin – those that do have a significant place in history, but not one that immediately occurs to a member of the general public.
The Billiard Ball: a story of theoretical scientist vs. wealthy (practical) engineer and all the jealously, resentment and competitiveness that comes hand in hand with that.
Mirror Image: this was the only story I had already read (it’s in the Robot Collection). Again, it’s Asimov marrying mystery and science fiction, this time using his three laws of robotics (and human nature, of course) to solve a plagiarism case between two mathematicians. In this anthology it is published with a new opening page which I cannot make head nor tail of! I have no idea how it relates to this story. But if you ignore that, it’s a great story.
In conclusion, if I wasn’t already in love with Asimov’s writings…
I’d be interested to know how familiar you guys are with Asimov’s books – let me know in the comments or via Twitter. Also, if you’d be interested in me writing more reviews of this type, do let me know – feedback is always appreciated.